Skip to content

Compelled Compassion: Government Intervention in the by Robert F. Weir (auth.), Arthur L. Caplan, Robert H. Blank,

By Robert F. Weir (auth.), Arthur L. Caplan, Robert H. Blank, Janna C. Merrick (eds.)

In April 1982, an little one boy was once born in Bloomington, Indiana, with Down syndrome and a faulty, yet surgically correctable, esophagus. His mom and dad refused to consent to surgical procedure or intravenous feeding. The medical institution unsuccessfully sought a court docket order to strength therapy, and appeals to better courts additionally failed. the kid, pointed out as child Doe by means of the scoop media, as a consequence died. The occasions in Bloomington turned the catalyst for motion through the Reagan management, the courts, and Congress that culminated in a federal coverage that makes failure to regard newborns with disabilities a kind of kid forget. This publication facilities at the public coverage elements of withholding therapy from significantly ailing newborns who're disabled. in particular, it offers with why the coverage used to be enacted and what influence it has had on wellbeing and fitness care employees, households, and babies. many of the members to this e-book spearheaded the early debate on withholding therapy. Anthony Shaw's manhattan instances journal article in 1972 used to be the 1st to deal with those concerns within the well known press. the next 12 months, he released a similar article within the New England magazine of drugs. additionally showing during this similar factor of NEJM, used to be the pathbreaking learn, coauthored by way of A. G. M. Campbell, on withholding therapy within the designated care nursery at Yale-New Haven medical institution. each one of those articles promoted a lot public discussion.

Show description

Read or Download Compelled Compassion: Government Intervention in the Treatment of Critically Ill Newborns PDF

Best government books

An Algebra of Soviet Power: Elite Circulation in the Belorussian Republic 1966-86 (Cambridge Russian, Soviet and Post-Soviet Studies)

The regulate of workplace has lengthy been considered as the major to knowing energy and coverage within the Soviet approach. What, although, money owed for this regulate of place of work? various traditional reviews have addressed this query by way of concentrating on the people who make up the Soviet elite at one time or one other.

The Blair Effect 2001-5

Tony Blair's powerful begin to his 3rd time period, along with his function in shooting the Olympic video games for Britain, his statesman-like dealing with of the aftermath of the terrorist assaults on London, his promise of a brand new begin to the eu Union and his management of the G8 summit at Gleneagles, has introduced his fairly lacklustre moment time period into sharp aid.

The Late Great U.S.A.: The Coming Merger With Mexico and Canada

Within the overdue nice united states, Jerome Corsi argues that the benignly-named safety and Prosperity Partnership, created at a gathering among George W. Bush, Stephen Harper and Vincente Fox, is in reality a similar type of neighborhood integration plan that led Europe to shape the european. based on Corsi, the elites in Europe in the back of the european knew that it might be essential to hide from the peoples of Europe what was once being performed of their identify till the method was once thus far complicated that it had turn into irreversible.

Indonesia Matters : Asia's Emerging Democratic Power

Indonesia is the fourth so much populous nation on the planet after China, India and the USA. it's also the world's biggest Muslim majority kingdom and the 3rd greatest democracy. Its economic system is at the moment the tenth greatest at the international scale. Indonesia is famous as an rising strength, and a revered member of the overseas neighborhood.

Additional resources for Compelled Compassion: Government Intervention in the Treatment of Critically Ill Newborns

Example text

Such a policy would surely not solve all of the problems of uncertainty in NICUs, but could provide a measure of greater certainty, ifbased on a consensus among neonatologists, in establishing a minimum weight limit for neonates who would be given life-sustaining treatment. Finally, by establishing a national insurance program, the federal government would help pay for the enormous costs that are involved in neonatal intensive care and specialized chronic-care units for young children. For the federal government to mandate that virtually all neonates, unless dying or permanently unconscious, be kept alive, and then to make no serious effort to help parents and institutions pay for that expensive care is unjust.

Congress also became involved, enacting legislation in 1984 that made medical neglect of newborns with disabilities a form of child abuse. The Policy Process A number of books have been written on the plight of newborns with disabilities. The focus of this book is the public policy aspects of the Baby Doe debate. A useful place to begin, therefore, is with an analysis of the context in which Conflict, Compromise, and Symbolism 37 public policy is made. The American political system is characterized by substantial government fragmentation.

Engl. J. Med. 318,677-683. Lichtig, L. K, Knauf, R A, Bartoletti, A, Wozniak, L. , and Ellis, W. C. (1989) Revising diagnosis-related groups for neonates. Pediatrics 84, 49-61. Lyon, J. (1985) Playing God in the Nursery (W. W. Norton, New York), p. 237. McCormick, R A (1986) The best interests of the baby. Second Opinion 2, 18-25. Marshall, P. , Halls, H. , James, S. , Grivell, A R, Goldstein, A, and Berry, M. N. (1989) The cost of intensive and special care of the newborn. Med. J. Australia 150,568-573.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.12 of 5 – based on 6 votes